Beyond Dialogue: What Will It Take to Rebuild Palestinian National Unity?
13
    

One of the most fundamental issues requiring reconsideration is the relationship between membership in the Palestine Liberation Organization and acceptance of its political program. Al-Masri questions how joining the PLO can be made conditional on endorsing commitments that, in his assessment, contradict Palestinian historical, legal, and political rights and undermine the national narrative.

He points in particular to the recognition of Israel and its right to live in security and peace, alongside the other commitments stemming from the Oslo Accords. Such commitments, he argues, are increasingly difficult to justify in light of Israel's genocide in Gaza, its ongoing encroachment on Palestinian land, the expansion of settlements, and escalating settler violence across the West Bank.

Rather than continuing to uphold recognition of Israel, Al-Masri argues that Palestinians should withdraw it and pursue Israel's international isolation and accountability for its crimes. He describes the original recognition as a major mistake, given that it was granted in exchange for recognition of the PLO itself, rather than recognition of Palestinian rights.

His argument rests on a distinction between the PLO's enduring national foundations and the political programs adopted by its leadership. The organization, he stresses, is not a faction, a private possession, or a government whose members must subscribe to a single political platform. It is supposed to serve as the common national home for Palestinians of all backgrounds, political currents, parties, and religious affiliations.

What should bind them together is a shared social contract, a national charter setting out fundamental values, principles, objectives, historical narrative, and the rules governing partnership. Such a framework would preserve political and intellectual pluralism while safeguarding the core elements of the Palestinian national project.

Political programs, by contrast, must remain adaptable. They can evolve in response to changing circumstances, needs, and balances of power without compromising the fundamental national principles on which the movement is built.

Al-Masri traces much of the current confusion to the post-Oslo period, when the Palestinian leadership endorsed an agreement containing provisions that contradicted significant parts of the National Charter. Under American, Israeli, regional, and international pressure, the PLO subsequently moved to amend most of its provisions, having secured recognition of the organization but not of Palestinian rights. This process began during a Palestinian National Council session held in Gaza in the presence of then-US President Bill Clinton.

Although the amendments did not complete all the required procedural and legal steps, the PLO was effectively left without a functioning national charter, a vacuum that, in Al-Masri's view, has had serious consequences.

Restoring the charter would provide a common foundation for all members, while leaving room for disagreement over political programs and approaches. Such differences, however, should not translate into competing authorities, fragmented leadership, or multiple centers of decision-making. Political pluralism, he insists, must coexist with a unified national decision.

National dialogue must address the existential threats facing Palestinians, not simply agree on election dates and procedures.

Al-Masri also warns against allowing the search for political consensus to come at the expense of fundamental rights. Palestinians must be free to adopt forms of struggle suited to the current circumstances, but this should never mean surrendering their right to resist occupation through the means permitted under international law.

The pursuit of an end to the occupation and the establishment of an independent Palestinian state within the 1967 borders must be understood within the broader right of the entire Palestinian people to self-determination. The Palestinian question cannot be confined to the West Bank and Gaza. It is, at its core, the question of a people whose homeland was occupied and whose majority was driven into exile.

Any lasting settlement must therefore address the rights of all Palestinians, including refugees' rights to return and compensation, and to live with dignity and equality in their homeland.

Another lesson from past negotiations, Al-Masri argues, is the danger of allowing Washington, Tel Aviv, or other regional and international capitals to dictate the boundaries of Palestinian political dialogue. Restricting discussions to what external powers are prepared to accept, without offering a fundamentally different political horizon, risks repeating the mistakes of the Oslo process.

The Palestinian side, he recalls, entered negotiations having already surrendered some of its most valuable cards. This allowed Israel to keep the talks going for years without meaningful progress, turning negotiations into an end in themselves before eventually refusing to negotiate altogether. The relationship was gradually stripped of its political substance, leaving security and economic coordination as its defining features.

In the process, the Palestinian Authority became a permanent mechanism for administering the population under occupation, while negotiations provided cover for successive Israeli governments to consolidate facts on the ground. With every passing year, the space for a viable political solution narrowed, while Israel's preferred outcome increasingly came to dominate what was considered politically possible.

For this reason, Al-Masri believes national dialogue must begin with a comprehensive assessment of the Palestinian political condition and the threats confronting the people, the land, their rights, and their national representation. It should develop a shared vision and practical programs before turning to institutional unification and electoral arrangements. These, in turn, should pave the way for free and fair elections whose results are respected, within a framework that protects pluralism and political competition through consensual democracy.

A dialogue without the people risks becoming little more than an exercise in managing the division.

The exclusion of society beyond the established factions has been another major weakness of Palestinian national dialogue. By allowing factional interests to take precedence over the broader national interest, previous talks have often served to manage the division rather than bring it to an end.

The problem has become even more acute as the factions' existing political programs and strategies have run their course, without serious reassessment or accountability and without the development of new alternatives. Increasingly, preserving the factions' own existence appears to have taken precedence over advancing the national project.

Al-Masri argues that this has deepened the division through unilateral decisions and contradictory approaches, ranging from growing accommodation with the prevailing reality to reckless attempts to bypass it. Both approaches, despite their differences, have weakened the factions and widened the gulf between them and the public.

Once commanding the support of an estimated 70 to 80 percent of Palestinians, the factions now account for no more than 50 percent, according to opinion polls cited by Al-Masri. This decline makes it all the more important to bring other constituencies into the political process, including women, young people, Palestinians in the diaspora, civil society organizations, the private sector, and independent figures.

The stakes are particularly high after more than two decades without elections and nearly two decades of political division, developments that have eroded the legitimacy of the various components of the Palestinian political system. Against a backdrop of institutional decline and widespread political failure, a dialogue confined to the factions can hardly claim to represent the full breadth of Palestinian society, let alone secure an agreement capable of ending the division.

A genuinely inclusive process, Al-Masri maintains, must restore the standing of the PLO as the national framework and sole legitimate representative of the Palestinian people, protect their collective interests, and give them a meaningful role in determining their future. It must also produce realistic programs capable of advancing Palestinian rights and the objectives of national and democratic liberation under the conditions prevailing today.

Palestinians cannot afford to look to those who brought them to this impasse to lead them out of it.

While acknowledging the importance of Arab, regional, and international support in achieving historic breakthroughs, Al-Masri cautions against allowing external powers to determine Palestinian positions and priorities. Doing so would come at the expense of the independence and distinctiveness of Palestinian decision-making.

Taking the international and regional context into account, he argues, is not the same as tying Palestinian policy to one political axis or another. Nor should Palestinians repeatedly pin their hopes on Israeli elections, then American elections, and then shifting regional and international developments. These, he warns, are “harmful illusions and losing bets.”

The first and foremost source of strength must be the Palestinian people themselves and the leverage they possess. Support from others should come next.

Given its just cause, moral standing, and capacity to bring together different constituencies, the Palestinian cause should not become a pawn in rival regional and international alignments. Instead, it should seek to become a common cause capable of attracting support across political divides. Its implications for security, stability, and peace extend well beyond Palestine, making it a matter of shared regional and international interest.

The article ultimately returns to a fundamental question: who will take up the banner of unity and revive the Palestinian national project?

Al-Masri argues that it is unrealistic to expect those responsible for the current predicament to emerge as its solution. Just as those who benefit from corruption are unlikely to lead the fight against it, those who caused the division, continue to deepen it, and benefit from its persistence cannot credibly be expected to bring it to an end.

As he puts it, “There can be no revolution without revolutionaries, no reform without reformers, and no democracy without democrats.”

The banner of freedom, dignity, justice, and democracy, and of national unity and the revival of the PLO and the national project, must be taken up by those willing to assume that responsibility. This does not mean excluding any faction or political actor from taking the initiative. On the contrary, the door should remain open to everyone prepared to act with the necessary will, commitment, and sense of national responsibility.

Ultimately, unity is not merely a political arrangement. It is a source of strength for the Palestinian leadership and every faction within it. Continued division, by contrast, leaves each party isolated and more vulnerable to American and Israeli dictates.

Al-Masri points to the Palestinian parties' acceptance of an externally imposed trusteeship council for Gaza, without Palestinian representation, as well as the agreement reached in late July between Hamas and the so-called Board of Peace, as examples of the consequences of this vulnerability.

For Palestinians, the choice is therefore not simply between another round of dialogue and continued deadlock. It is between reproducing a political order that has repeatedly failed and undertaking the deeper renewal needed to restore national unity, independent decision-making, and the people's role in shaping their own future.

 

Note: This is not a literal, word by word translation of the original article. It is an English adaptation that conveys all of the original article’s ideas and follows its argument and sequence. Direct quotations are taken from the original article.

This is a test version of the website and it is still under construction and development.